Secrets in Jamaica vs. Sandals in St. Lucia?

I've been to Secrets St James 3 times and I loved it every time. No complaints at all

I haven't been to either but our friends just came back from their honeymoon at Sandals in St.Lucia and they loved it! We're going for our honeymoon in June.

I would take the advice of your travel agent. She is the expert and will have insider knowledge.

View Quoted Comment

Is there a reason why you chose Secrets St. James over Wild Orchid? I'm leaning more towards Wild Orchid.

View Quoted Comment No reason at all. They're really the same place, the rooms look exactly the same and share all the same pools, bars, restaurants etc. The only difference is one is a tad closer to walk to the restaurants